On a dark April night in rural Hebron, New York, 20-year-old Kaylin Gillis and her friends are searching for a party when they turn down the wrong driveway. At first, it seems like an awkward mistake, the kind anyone could make on rural roads with no streetlights and no clear signs. But within minutes, the night turns violent, leaving investigators to piece together what happened in the darkness.

Get commercial free access to over a decade of Sword and Scale's true crime podcasts at http://swordandscale.com